Multi Locksmiths shield and key logoMulti LocksmithsSecurity & locksmiths · Malvern East

Advice ·

Rekeying vs replacing locks: which one do you actually need?

Rekeying changes who can open a lock. Replacement changes the lock itself. Most people are quoted the wrong one.

What rekeying actually does

Rekeying is the process of removing a lock cylinder, changing the internal pin stack, and cutting a new key to match. The hardware stays on the door. Every key that used to work stops working, and the new key takes over.

That makes rekeying the correct answer to a people problem: a lost key, a former tenant, a departed employee, an ex-partner, or a renovation where a dozen trades held your front door key at some point. Nothing is wrong with your lock — the problem is who can open it.

The cost sits mainly in labour and key cutting, which is why rekeying four cylinders is generally well under the cost of four new locks. On period homes it has a second advantage: original hardware stays on the door instead of being thrown out.

When replacement is the honest recommendation

Replacement is right when the lock itself is the problem. A cylinder that needs force to turn is worn internally, and re-pinning a worn cylinder produces a lock that will fail again within a year. A body with a cracked casing, a stripped cam or a failed spring cannot be brought back to a safe tolerance.

There is also a security-standard argument. Some older and budget cylinders are known to be vulnerable to snapping or bumping, and no amount of rekeying changes that. If your front door still has a lock that can be defeated in under a minute by someone with a common tool, rekeying it just gives the same weakness a new key.

Finally, replacement is sometimes the cheaper route to a single-key house. If two of your five cylinders cannot be keyed to match the others, swapping those two for compatible cylinders costs less than fighting the incompatibility.

A practical way to decide

Ask three questions. Does the key turn smoothly? Is the hardware itself in good condition? Is the lock type appropriate for the door and its exposure? Three yeses point to rekeying. Any no points to replacing that specific lock — not necessarily all of them.

Be sceptical of a quote that recommends replacing every lock in a house without inspecting them. There are situations where that is right, particularly on homes with mixed budget hardware, but it should be explained door by door with reasons.

It is also reasonable to mix the two. A common outcome on the homes we attend is rekeying three sound cylinders, replacing one that is worn out, and adding a lock to a rear door that never had one — all keyed to the same key.

What to ask a locksmith before booking

Ask whether they will rekey on site or take cylinders away. Ask how many keys are included and whether extras are charged. Ask whether every external door will end up on the same key, and if not, why. Ask when the price will be confirmed before work starts.

Any locksmith who cannot answer those questions clearly is not the one to trust with your key control. The whole point of this work is knowing exactly who can open your door.

Want this looked at properly?

An experienced technician can tell you in five minutes what an article cannot. 03 7074 8967, any hour.

Speak to a technician on 03 7074 8967

Open now24 hours, 7 daysCall 03 7074 8967

Keep reading

Call 03 7074 8967